Peanut Butter Still Healthy? Why Clinical Nutritionists Prefer Almond Butter

Written by

Louise W Lu, PhD, MPH, BMLS

Reviewed by

Alexandra V Goldberg, Registered Dietitian

Introduction: Peanut Butter vs. Almond Butter — Which One Is Right for Your Family?

Recently, a mum in our nutrition coaching program messaged our team with a question that many parents can relate to:

“One is Almond Butter⬅️, and the other says Chia & Flaxseed Peanut Butter➡️. They both look healthy—so which one is better for my family?”

Many people assume all nut butters are more or less the same—just pick based on taste, price, or whether the label says “high protein” or “superfood.” But in reality, different nut butters vary a lot in their fat profile, nutrient density, and impact on your health.

In this article, we’ll walk you through everything from fatty acid structure and micronutrient content to real-world metabolism research:

• Why that “healthy-looking” peanut butter may not be ideal for everyday use
• Why clinical nutritionists are increasingly recommending almond butter instead
• And how to choose the best nut butter for your kids, your skin, or your own metabolic health

👉 Click here to jump straight to Section 05 for the comparison results

01｜Why Has Peanut Butter Been Considered a “Healthy Food”?

For a long time, peanut butter was seen as the perfect combo of “plant protein + healthy fats.” It’s naturally plant-based, cholesterol-free, and provides protein and vitamin E—making it sound way healthier than butter or lard.

Kids love it, and parents feel it’s “nutritious.” Fitness folks love its high protein and satiating power, and many mums feel it’s a better option than jam—less sugar, more nutrients.

Even plenty of nutritionists have recommended it: a spoonful of peanut butter in oatmeal, yoghurt, or salad—quick, tasty, and “healthy” sounding.

But here’s the catch: the actual fat profile—especially its linoleic acid content—might not be as ideal as we thought, especially when it’s eaten in large amounts or too frequently.

02｜But Is Peanut Butter Still Healthy in Real Life?

In our previous post, “Is Your Cooking Oil Feeding Tumours?” we discussed how excessive intake of omega-6 fatty acids—especially linoleic acid—might contribute to health issues when not balanced with enough omega-3.

Linoleic acid isn’t the enemy. It’s an essential fatty acid that plays a role in immune function and cell health. The issue is about quantity and balance—especially when omega-3 intake is low.

The takeaway is simple: peanut butter is fine in moderation, but don’t overdo it—and don’t neglect omega-3s.

If you already have inflammation, insulin resistance, or a family history of cancer, then peanut butter—rich in linoleic acid—may not be the best everyday food.

We also often see people with acne-prone skin getting worse after regularly consuming peanut butter or nut butters. It might be due to low-grade inflammation from excessive omega-6 fats.

Peanut butter isn’t toxic. But it shouldn’t be treated like a staple. Especially if your omega-3 levels are low, loading up on omega-6 fats could backfire.

03｜Peanut Butter vs. Almond Butter: A Nutrient Showdown

Many people think nut butters are all the same—switching to almond butter just means a different taste and a higher price tag. But that’s not the whole story.

If you care about fat quality, micronutrient density, and antioxidant power, almond butter clearly has the edge.

Here’s what we found:

• Peanut butter has more linoleic acid—about 3.6g per tablespoon versus 2.1g in almond butter. If you’re already getting too much omega-6, almond butter is the better balance.
• Almond butter delivers more vitamin E, calcium, and magnesium, supporting antioxidant defense, bone strength, and nerve metabolism—especially beneficial for women and growing children.
• It also packs more fiber, helping with fullness and gut health.
• Both are similar in protein, but almond butter offers a better ratio of monounsaturated fats.

📊 The table is long—scroll vertically to view all data:

_{Note: 1 gram (g) = 1000 milligrams (mg); kcal = kilocalories, a common measure of dietary energy.}

If you care about fat quality, inflammation control, or nutrient density, almond butter takes a small win in this showdown—and it could mean big gains for your health.

04｜Who Should Be Cautious About Peanut Butter, and Who Should Switch to Almond Butter?

Not everyone should treat peanut butter as a daily staple. If you're in one of these groups, it’s time to reconsider:

❌ People who should limit peanut butter:

• Those prone to acne or inflammatory skin issues: Too much linoleic acid may worsen low-grade inflammation.
• Individuals with insulin resistance or blood sugar issues: High omega-6 intake can reduce insulin sensitivity.
• Those with a family history of breast cancer or heart disease: Omega-6 may aggravate some chronic disease risks.
• People watching their weight: Peanut butter is calorie-dense and easy to overeat.

✅ Who might benefit more from almond butter:

• Women and growing children: Almond butter is richer in calcium, magnesium, and vitamin E—great for bones, skin, and nerves.
• People sensitive to inflammation or hormone shifts: Especially those with PCOS, PMS, or autoimmune flare-ups.
• Fitness-focused individuals: Almond butter offers high protein with better-quality fats for muscle recovery.

05｜How to Choose a Good Almond Butter? Don’t Be Fooled by “Chia Flax” Labels

Now, let’s answer the original question from our nutrition client: Should I buy almond butter or the chia & flax peanut butter?

The first step when choosing nut butters is simple—flip the jar over and check the ingredient list.

Click image to view full size

Take a closer look at these two real product photos:

• Almond butter: ultra-clean ingredients—99.5% roasted almonds + a pinch of sea salt.
• Chia & flax peanut butter: despite its name, here’s what’s actually inside:
  • Peanuts make up 90% of the product
  • Chia seeds are just 7%
  • And flax? There’s no whole flaxseed—only 2.5% “flaxseed fibre” added.

This is important: Flaxseed fibre ≠ whole flaxseed. It only provides fiber and lacks the full omega-3 nutrition that comes from whole flaxseeds.

So even though the branding screams “superfoods,” the reality is: it’s still mostly peanut butter, with chia and flax added more for label appeal than true nutritional value.

Next, let’s look at the nutrition label:

• Per tablespoon (15g), almond butter contains slightly more total fat—but much more heart-healthy monounsaturated fat.
• It also offers significantly more vitamin E, calcium, and magnesium.
• The “chia & flax” version, meanwhile, provides very limited omega-3 benefits, as it contains no actual flaxseed oil.

06｜Final Thoughts: Is That Nut Butter Jar Still the Best Choice?

Peanut butter isn’t bad—it just shouldn’t be eaten daily without limits.

If you’re aiming for better health and less inflammation, almond butter is the smarter pick.

Authors:

Louise W Lu

Registered Nutritionist (NZ Reg. 82021301), PhD of Nutrition Science, Honorary Academic at the University of Auckland. Louise blends clinical research with public health to help people eat better and live stronger.

All Posts  •  Website

Alexandra V Goldberg

Registered Dietitian (NZ Reg. 20-02273) and expert in nutrition, medicinal chemistry, and skincare. Alexandra helps clients reach their health goals with science-backed strategies in post-op recovery, feeding tolerance, and weight management.

All Posts  •  Website